MASSENA -- What started as a 15-minute public comment period ended with an expletive laden tirade and Village of Massena Police on standby as the Massena Town Board attempted to move into executive …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
To continue reading, you will need to either log in to your subscriber account, or purchase a new subscription.
If you are a digital subscriber with an active, online-only subscription then you already have an account here. Just reset your password if you've not yet logged in to your account on this new site.
Otherwise, click here to view your options for subscribing.
Please log in to continue |
MASSENA -- What started as a 15-minute public comment period ended with an expletive laden tirade and Village of Massena Police on standby as the Massena Town Board attempted to move into executive session following another contentious meeting.
More than 100 locals, many of them from the Akwesasne Mohawk Reservation, were in attendance Nov. 18 to voice further opposition to data centers in the region.
The meeting began with one attendee interrupting normal business to place two bottles filled with water she said was contaminated due to the superfund sites formerly operated by General Motors and Alcoa.
"That's the water we have to drink because of you. Drink it and tell me it's fine," she said.
At the heart of the argument is the NYDIG expansion project, located at the former Alcoa East location next to the reservation.
The project would see new construction to create 1.5 million square feet to house computer systems, however what the intended use would be has yet to be publicly disclosed.
Members of the public have questioned whether the site would still be used for Bitcoin mining and collocation services, while others have openly suggested an Artificial Intelligence (AI) firm was already in talks to call the new facilities home.
To date, NYDIG officials have publicly declined to say who was in active negotiations to lease the spaces, merely saying it was “a major tech firm” during previous meetings.
Many members of the Tribe have voiced direct opposition to the project, saying the Superfund site remains contaminated with PCBs that are known to cause numerous forms of cancer, birth defects and chronic illnesses.
But those comments turned personal quickly when accusations were leveled at the town board.
One resident went so far as to issue a thinly veiled threat toward board members, saying "when something happens to a family member" there would be consequences for the board.
"When something happens, I'll be coming after each of you on the board," she said.
Others spoke of the major health issues facing numerous members of the Tribe, due in large part to contaminated water sources from years of PCBs being dumped from industrial plants in Massena.
Federal authorities undertook a major remediation project in the Grasse River in recent years, dredging multiple sections of the river
Many question whether those efforts have done more harm than good by disturbing the contaminants.
Some attendees spoke of the demands on the power grid, saying Massena could ill afford what amounted to corporate welfare at a time when residents are already struggling to pay utility bills and grocery bills.
Local activist Dave Fenton, who has been an outspoken critic of the project, used his three minutes to address the board and request representatives from the New York Power Authority, National Grid, Massena Electric and other stakeholders attend the meetings to address the public themselves.
Fenton said other locations that play home to data centers, in particular in Virginia, have seen sharp increases in utility rates.
In one case, Fenton said, local municipalities saw an increase of more than 300% in utility bills.
“We can ill afford the same to happen in Massena,” he said.
To date, no representatives from the organizations have been in attendance, nor have they addressed the proposed project in any capacity.
Members of Mohawks United in Safety and Health (MUSH) were also in attendance, with Jacob Thompson addressing the board.
Thompson said it was a matter of public health, not just for the Tribe, but for the entire community and those that surround Massena.
He urged the board to slow the project down and seriously consider the major health consequences of allowing it to proceed.
Thompson said Tribal members previously met with NYDIG officials to voice concerns and open dialogue, however future meetings were not planned.
He said when Tribal and MUSH members asked NYDIG officials if they intended to continue to meet they were brushed off and told no more meetings would be necessary.
A NYDIG official could be heard addressing the comments with Thompson following the meeting, saying he felt they were "disingenuous" while saying NYDIG remained committed to open dialogue with Tribal members and leadership.
Fellow MUSH member Karontawakon Roundpoint also addressed concerns with the project, questioning what would be done to ensure public safety through appropriate staffing and redundancies, including appropriate staffing.
He also requested the board consider what changes would be required for first responders, including training and equipping them to respond to situations that could occur at the site.
Both Thompson and Roundpoint, along with Ronni Sunday and Marina Johnson-Zafiris have played a major role in raising awareness about the health concerns and risk factors associated with data centers through numerous public outreach events, including presentations at the Massena Public Library and other community locations.
The meeting eventually came to an abrupt closure following Larry Thompson's public comments, during which he chastised the board for endangering future generations with "short-sighted" decision making that would "impact the next seven generations."
Thompson took a moment to criticize town Attorney Eric Gustafson as well for his involvement in the regulatory process for data centers and what he felt was a lack of transparency in the process.
When he asked for additional time, Thompson was cut off by Supervisor Ray Lancto who said he was holding Thompson to the same three-minute standard everyone else was held to.
Thompson shot back, saying he merely wanted two more minutes to address the board.
"Three minutes is not nearly enough. Even five minutes is not. What is another two minutes of your time with a matter as serious as this?" he asked.
Board Member Adrian Taraska spoke up, saying it was not just a matter of Thompson's time but of everyone in attendance, including the town board who still had business to address in executive session.
Taraska's comments led others to criticize the board for what they felt was a prohibitive public comment period.
Others damned the board and suggested they had little concern for Tribal members whose families have long suffered health issues not of their creation.
"Easy for you to say because your family doesn't suffer the way ours do. You don't have the same health issues we do. Leukemia, cancer, every family has it," one member of the public said.
Taraska rebutted the claims, saying his family too has suffered health issues in the past but noted they "were not anyone else's business."
The comments made were the final in public session as Lancto ended public comment past the 15 minute allocation, eventually moving into executive session.
As some members of the public began to file out, multiple members of the public took time to further criticize the board for their actions or in some cases lack thereof as it pertains to the recently failed attempt at securing a local moratorium.
"It's all about money and you don't give a f—- about any of us. Who is lining your pockets? Who is paying you off?" one member of the public could be heard yelling.
Though Massena Police were on standby, no officers took direct action or removed members of the public following the meeting.
Town officials will meet again Dec. 3 at 4:30 p.m. to take public comments regarding a proposed local law that pertains to the siting, permitting and environmental review process for data centers.