X

Franklin County and St. Regis Mohawk tribe strike agreement on land dispute

Posted 6/14/23

BY JEFF CHUDZINSKI North Country This Week MASSENA — The St. Regis Mohawk Tribe and Franklin County have agreed on a settlement over long disputed lands stemming from litigation that began in 1982. …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Franklin County and St. Regis Mohawk tribe strike agreement on land dispute

Posted

BY JEFF CHUDZINSKI

North Country This Week

MASSENA — The St. Regis Mohawk Tribe and Franklin County have agreed on a settlement over long disputed lands stemming from litigation that began in 1982.

State legislators in both the Assembly and Senate approved a bill that will allow the Governor to officially sign off on the agreement. The legislation was co-sponsored by Senator Dan Stec (R,C-Queensbury).

The litigation also named St. Lawrence County but after years of negotiations an agreement was struck in 2013 between St. Lawrence County and the tribe. A Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) was officially signed in 2014.

The land in question in Franklin County is in the towns of Fort Covington and Bombay.

With the agreement now struck, some finer details need to be worked out.

According to the bill, “The settlement agreement must be considerably consistent with both a memorandum of understanding between the Governor, the St. Regis Mohawk Tribe, and the county of St. Lawrence, and a resolution adopted by the county of Franklin on June 5, 2023.”

The bill goes on further, saying that the agreement “will be deemed ratified by the Legislature upon the certification by the Governor to the Temporary President of the Senate, the Speaker of the Assembly, and the Secretary of State that the agreement has received the requisite federal approvals and that the underlying litigation has been dismissed with prejudice.”

According to St. Lawrence County Attorney Steve Button, who sat in on the negotiations on behalf of St. Lawrence County, details that still need to be hammered out include who would be responsible for road repair, fire districts and service, ambulatory services, financial compensation, taxation and other similar aspects.

Stec, who was also involved in the final negotiations, said he was pleased to see this stalemate end between the county and the state and is optimistic a final agreement between all parties is close to being completed.

“I’m glad that after 41 years of negotiation, a settlement agreement between New York State and Franklin and St. Lawrence Counties over the St. Regis Mohawk Tribe land claim has been reached,” said Stec. “One of the major roadblocks to resolving this issue was getting the state government to provide fair compensation to both counties. I’ve been working with state and county officials to negotiate a fair deal to this long-running stalemate.

“We are one step closer to a final resolution and I’m optimistic this long standing issue will finally be settled in the near future,” he concluded.

One complication moving forward that will need to be addressed is the inhabited properties in Franklin County.

In Franklin County, numerous homes are in the areas that will now be deemed tribal territory.

The details surrounding taxation and support services will still need to be hammered out for those properties, he said.

In question as well was the contested “Massena Square Mile,” a section in the village of Massena that many tribal members contend is also tribal land.

In a previous interview with North Country This Week, Button confirmed the contested territory was not included in the MOU signed in 2014, essentially mooting the point of the argument.